By Craig Scotter

PORT VALE 1 Butterworth 57 PORT VALE: Stevens 7, Smith 7, Jones 7, Hall 7, Worrall 7 (Robinson 66, 6), Garrity 7, Conlon 7, Benning 7, Butterworth 8 (Politic 78, 6), Massey 6, Wilson 6 (Odubeko 53, 6). Subs not used: Stone, Cass, Charsley, Pett. CHARLTON ATH 0 CHARLTON ATHLETIC: Maynard-Brewer 5, Clare 6, Lavelle 6 (Morgan 83, 7), Inniss 6, Sessegnon 7, Rak-Sakyi 6, Dobson 7, Fraser 6 (Forster-Caskey 76, 6), Blackett-Taylor 6 (Campbell 77, 6), Stockley 6 (Aneke 58, 6), Kirk 6 (Payne 77, 6). Subs not used: Harness, Elerewe. Att: 7,604 Rating: ★☆&...